Portal 2 developer commentary: Difference between revisions

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Rattman's Den commentary node is encoded as SSTV, containing three presentation slides
m (→‎Wheatley's As Level Designer: added test chamber where it’s found)
(Rattman's Den commentary node is encoded as SSTV, containing three presentation slides)
 
(5 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 38: Line 38:


=== Elevator Fatigue ===
=== Elevator Fatigue ===
{{Quotation | Marcus Egan
{{Quotation | Marcus Egan, Laser Platform
| We found that playtesters were getting fatigued at solving so many complex test chambers in a row. So, instead of a routine elevator ride to the next puzzle, we added a long funnel ride with some destruction to give players a short break while reminding them of the facility's state of disrepair.
| We found that playtesters were getting fatigued at solving so many complex test chambers in a row. So, instead of a routine elevator ride to the next puzzle, we added a long funnel ride with some destruction to give players a short break while reminding them of the facility's state of disrepair.
}}
}}
Line 83: Line 83:


=== Kill Your Television ===
=== Kill Your Television ===
{{Quotation | Zachary Franks
{{Quotation | Zachary Franks, Stop the Box
| In each of Wheatley's test chambers there is always a monitor with Wheatley on it. While placing the monitor in this level, one of our designers thought it would be funny if the monitor was the target of the faith plate and would get broken if the player or the box flew into it. We thought the gag worked well and decided to make every monitor breakable.
| In each of Wheatley's test chambers there is always a monitor with Wheatley on it. While placing the monitor in this level, one of our designers thought it would be funny if the monitor was the target of the faith plate and would get broken if the player or the box flew into it. We thought the gag worked well and decided to make every monitor breakable.
}}
}}


=== Nonlinear Progression ===
=== Nonlinear Progression ===
{{Quotation | Greg Cherlin
{{Quotation | Greg Cherlin, Laser Catapult
| The original layout of this chamber started out much more linear; essentially a sequence of rooms that the player had to progress through somewhat blindly – not knowing what the next goal might be until they got there.  Early versions contained an extra puzzle beyond the reflector cube, but due to the linear path, it took players so long to get to it, that they were confused about which elements were still relevant. This drove us to make the level nonlinear.  To make it easier for players to visualize the puzzle, we condensed the overall test space and moved the exit near the start. This helped the players see where they had to go and which objects would help them get there.
| The original layout of this chamber started out much more linear; essentially a sequence of rooms that the player had to progress through somewhat blindly – not knowing what the next goal might be until they got there.  Early versions contained an extra puzzle beyond the reflector cube, but due to the linear path, it took players so long to get to it, that they were confused about which elements were still relevant. This drove us to make the level nonlinear.  To make it easier for players to visualize the puzzle, we condensed the overall test space and moved the exit near the start. This helped the players see where they had to go and which objects would help them get there.
}}
}}
Line 153: Line 153:


=== Birdbrain ===
=== Birdbrain ===
{{Quotation | Erik Wolpaw
{{Quotation | Erik Wolpaw, Ceiling Button
| One of the larger plot holes that PotatOS introduced was: She’s your buddy now. She’s got the same goals as you. So why isn’t she helping you solve the tests? The real answer is, obviously, that if she did help you solve the tests there’d be no game. One solution we we came up with was for the bird from Act 3 to keep swooping in and pecking bits of her off your gun. As the bird kept eating the part of her that knew how to solve the tests, PotatOS would actually get dumber over time. For technical reasons, this ended up being impossible to execute, so we ended up finding another solution. Some of us though will always have a place in our heart for the bird solution.
| One of the larger plot holes that PotatOS introduced was: She’s your buddy now. She’s got the same goals as you. So why isn’t she helping you solve the tests? The real answer is, obviously, that if she did help you solve the tests there’d be no game. One solution we we came up with was for the bird from Act 3 to keep swooping in and pecking bits of her off your gun. As the bird kept eating the part of her that knew how to solve the tests, PotatOS would actually get dumber over time. For technical reasons, this ended up being impossible to execute, so we ended up finding another solution. Some of us though will always have a place in our heart for the bird solution.
}}
}}


=== Evil Wheatley ===
=== Evil Wheatley ===
{{Quotation | Noel McGinn
{{Quotation | Noel McGinn, Polarity
| Finding the right balance for Evil Wheatley was difficult, because we still wanted him to be the bumbling idiot from the first half of the game, but at the same time, there had to be some sense that he was dangerous now, otherwise there wasn't much tension for the big finale. Fortunately, Stephen Merchant did a great job of intercutting funny bumbling Wheatley with occasional outbursts of power-mad, villainous Wheatley.
| Finding the right balance for Evil Wheatley was difficult, because we still wanted him to be the bumbling idiot from the first half of the game, but at the same time, there had to be some sense that he was dangerous now, otherwise there wasn't much tension for the big finale. Fortunately, Stephen Merchant did a great job of intercutting funny bumbling Wheatley with occasional outbursts of power-mad, villainous Wheatley.
}}
}}
Line 419: Line 419:
=== Rattman’s Den ===
=== Rattman’s Den ===
{{Quotation | Adam Foster, Pull the Rug
{{Quotation | Adam Foster, Pull the Rug
| *Very disturbing computer noises*}}
| Portal 2 Announcement ARG
* Created by people working on Portal 2
* Intended for enthusiastic superfans
* Budget of less than $100
* Portal updated to include radios, broadcasting mysterious SSTV images
* Certain images contained pieces of an MD5 hash of a phone number
* Phone number led to an old-fashioned BBS
* Estimated time to 'solve': 7 hours
* Actual time to solve: 7 hours 16 minutes
 
Portal 2 SSTV Images
* Analogue format used in HAM radio
* Watching video of ISS SSTV with SSTV software running, sound from laptop speakers unexpectedly picked up by microphone
* Peculiar squeaking and beeping, degrades in visually interesting ways
* Photos of Valve whiteboards, equipment and anything science-related lying around
* Finding radios in Portal made for fun meta-game - everyone could join in
 
Aperture Laboratories BBS
* Single analogue phone line in a designer's kitchen (phone systems in Valve office too modern)
* Old PC running Linux, attached to a 2400 bps modem from 1987 (via USB to serial adapter)
* mgetty to handle calls, custom PHP script looping through plot fragments and home-made ANSI-art conversions of Portal 2 artwork
* Transmitted about 20MB of data in total
* Phoneline constantly engaged!
* Several spare modems in case one died - none did
* SSH backdoor for updates and monitoring (possible to watch exactly what people were seeing as they dialed in)
* Combined might of internets is terrifying
}}


== See also ==
== See also ==
1

edit

Navigation menu