User talk:Cartoonmaster: Difference between revisions

Line 17:

:::So, should the unused lines from all the different chapters just be dumped at the end in their own section? Do they get any mention or ref/link as to where they came from/were to go? (I know the strikes are messy looking - it was just my working, er...process.) I know, for instance, on the Cave Johnson voice line page, there are some unused rants with the parts of it that made it into the game bolded. On GLaDOS's voice line page, the unused lines largely have notes as to what they were supposed to be (ex. "computerized voice" versions of the "low voice" boss fight rants used in Portal [1], lines referring to different unused content). Hm, so at the cost of easy side-by-side comparison within chapters, should they be categorized first under "unused" and then again by chapter/source? —[[User:Cartoonmaster|Cartoonmaster]] 04:19, 21 December 2011 (UTC)

:I think something like this would be ideal:

== Chapter name ==

{{tlx|hatnote|Some unused voice files were created for this chapter (with a link to the section anchor)}}

=== Test chamber x ===

{{tlx|hatnote|Some unused voice files were created for this chamber (with a link to the section anchor)}}

* Voice line 1

* Voice line 2

...

== Unused ==

=== Chapter name ===

* Voice line line meant to be use in this chapter but not in any particular chamber (''Explanation as to why'')

==== Test chamber x ====

* Voice line meant to be in chamber x but unused (''Explanation as to why'')

=== Misc. ===

* Voice line that isn't used nor fits in any particular chapter (''Explanation as to why'')

But I'm not sure it would be applicable to all voice line pages, so I dunno, but at least it provides an easy link to the unused voice files for each section. Having them within each regular section would be more handy perhaps, but it would also get messier with the explanations about them being cut. — [[User:WindPower|Wind]] 05:15, 21 December 2011 (UTC)

@@ Line 17: / Line 17: @@
 :::So, should the unused lines from all the different chapters just be dumped at the end in their own section? Do they get any mention or ref/link as to where they came from/were to go? (I know the strikes are messy looking - it was just my working, er...process.) I know, for instance, on the Cave Johnson voice line page, there are some unused rants with the parts of it that made it into the game bolded. On GLaDOS's voice line page, the unused lines largely have notes as to what they were supposed to be (ex. "computerized voice" versions of the "low voice" boss fight rants used in Portal [1], lines referring to different unused content). Hm, so at the cost of easy side-by-side comparison within chapters, should they be categorized first under "unused" and then again by chapter/source? —[[User:Cartoonmaster|Cartoonmaster]] 04:19, 21 December 2011 (UTC)
+:I think something like this would be ideal:
+  == Chapter name ==
+  {{tlx|hatnote|Some unused voice files were created for this chapter (with a link to the section anchor)}}
+  === Test chamber x ===
+  {{tlx|hatnote|Some unused voice files were created for this chamber (with a link to the section anchor)}}
+  * Voice line 1
+  * Voice line 2
+  ...
+  == Unused ==
+  === Chapter name ===
+  * Voice line line meant to be use in this chapter but not in any particular chamber (''Explanation as to why'')
+  ==== Test chamber x ====
+  * Voice line meant to be in chamber x but unused (''Explanation as to why'')
+  === Misc. ===
+  * Voice line that isn't used nor fits in any particular chapter (''Explanation as to why'')
+But I'm not sure it would be applicable to all voice line pages, so I dunno, but at least it provides an easy link to the unused voice files for each section. Having them within each regular section would be more handy perhaps, but it would also get messier with the explanations about them being cut. — [[User:WindPower|Wind]] 05:15, 21 December 2011 (UTC)